Dodge Omni/Aries & Plymouth Horizon/Reliant America – Brilliant Idea, Brilliantly Executed

America Series Flickr

The introduction of the dirt cheap Yugo GV and Hyundai Excel for 1986 caused many alarms to go off in Detroit.  The Big Three automakers were still trying to compete with Japan’s lower manufacturing costs, and now here were two new entrants at even lower price points.  Chrysler Chairman & CEO Lee Iacocca, a marketing master extraordinaire, saw it as an opportunity to breathe new life into two cars – really one car with two nameplates – that were about to drive off into the sunset.  The result was a resounding success to the extent that it did it again a year later with two more moribund cars.

1990 plymouth horizon 4dr

Each manufacturer responded to the Yugo/Excel in their own way.  GM assumed that the imported Chevrolet Sprint (Suzuki Cultus), which was introduced the previous year, and the ancient Chevette, both with starting prices in the mid-five thousand price range, could cover that end of the market.  Ford wouldn’t field a competitor in that price range until 1988 with the Korean-built Festiva (Kia Pride).

Chrysler’s Dodge Omni and Plymouth Horizon were in their 9th model year.  Revolutionary when they were introduced in the fall of 1977 as the first American-made, transverse-engine, front-drive compacts from one of the Big Three manufacturers, they were now outclassed by nearly every competitor save the Chevette.  Their intended replacements, the Dodge Shadow and Plymouth Sundance, were only months away.Horizon America A New Kind of Value

The Colt, which was a rebadged Mitsubishi Mirage, and Omni/Horizon started at either side of six thousand.  Chrysler knew the Omnirizon could still be competitive, but not at $6,209 for a 9-year-old car that didn’t give you anything more than the fresh-faced $4,995 Excel or the $3,998 Yugo (being based on the Fiat 127 introduced in 1971, its face wasn’t quite so fresh).  The base 1986 Omnirizon was powered by a Peugeot-supplied 1.6-liter engine and 4-speed manual transaxle which was not far removed from the 1.5-liter/4-speed combo in the base Excel, with no radio, basic instrumentation, no power steering, no air conditioning (not even optional with the 1.6), and no rear defroster or wiper.  Not a lot of value for the price.  Just lowering the price wouldn’t cut it, either, as there was not enough margin to make it meaningful.

However, Chrysler still cut the margin as much as they could.  Since the tooling had long-since been paid for, and the price of the pair had only risen since their introduction, there was more margin to play with than there would have been earlier.

 

Horizon America Features

 

The second component was simplification.  The eighties were still the Burger-King-Have-It-Your-Way era for the Big Three, and you could equip your Omnirizon like a stripper (not the good kind), little two-tone luxury car, outlandish hot hatch, or anywhere in between.  With the America program, Chrysler did a complete 180.  The old base/SE/GLH trim lines went away, and now there was just one trim, coincidentally called “America”.  The 10+ solid colors and various two-tone options were trimmed to just six solid colors.  Option choices went from twelve to five, with three discount packages, air conditioning, and AM/FM cassette stereo.  Overall, there were 704 fewer parts for the factories to manage according to Car & Driver’s interview with Don Gshwind, Vice President of Product Development, in the review of the Horizon America (Oct. 1986).

The third component was value.  As I described above, the base Omnirizon wasn’t far removed from the base Excel.  Therefore, added to the list of standard equipment were the previously optional 2.2-liter engine (which was now the only engine), 5-speed manual transaxle, Rallye instrument cluster with tachometer, and rear window defroster with wiper.  And, of course, it still came with Chrysler’s famous 5-year/50,000-mile powertrain warranty, which it had come with since 1982.  An ’86 model in this configuration would be a $6,899 car.

Even with reduced margin and simplification, this would still not get the price competitive with Hyundai.  Therefore, the fourth component was outright cost cutting.  According to Gschwind, Chrysler convinced suppliers to lower their prices.  In addition, they negotiated a much more favorable labor contract with the Belvidere plant UAW, got the State of Illinois to pay for job training, and persuaded the dealers to reduce their profit margin.

Horizon America Ad

The America was released in May 1986 with an astonishingly low $5,499 price tag – just $500 more than the Excel – though Chrysler increased the price to $5,799 in October.  In May alone, sales jumped 43.2%.  Overall Chrysler sold 146,356 units for the 1987 model year (which was actually slightly less than the shortened 1986 model year, but it includes a 6-month shutdown while the tooling was moved to a new factory).  Chevrolet responded by cutting the price of the Chevette to $4,995 for its final model year but it was gone before the calendar flipped to 1987.

The strong 1987 showing for the Omnirizon is impressive considering they were sharing the showroom with the cars that were intended to replace them.  The Shadow/Sundance, which were introduced the month after the America cars, sold 151,735 units that year, split almost evenly between Dodge and Plymouth, and that’s where Chrysler reclaimed much of the lost profit margin.  Since the decision was made to keep the Omnirizon around, the new K-based twins were marketed as “premium” subcompacts.  The two-door started at $7,599, with an additional $200 for the four-door, and were relatively well equipped.  “Premium” options included items usually reserved for larger cars at this time, like power windows/locks/mirrors, turbo engine (as an option on any model, not just a limited-edition sports model like the GLH), tilt steering wheel, cruise control, and alloy wheels.

Sundance

The America initiative was not applied to the Charger/Turismo, which received the standard price increases over the 1986 models.  However, you could still get the hot Shelby edition of the Charger, including the turbo engine, for those who missed the GLH.  They were gone after the 1987 model year.

Based on the success of the Omnirizon America, Chrysler introduced the Aries/Reliant America for 1988.  Trims were cut down to just the LE with roughly same standard equipment as the Aries SE/Reliant LE of 1987.  Color choices were cut from 8 to 7, but the number of options were reduced and grouped into packages.  In an apples-to-apples comparison, the 1987 Reliant LE was $8,134 and the 1988 model was $6,995.  I couldn’t find any information on whether the same cost-cutting measures were applied to the Aries/Reliant America, but I can only assume that they were based on how much less the latter car retailed.

Reliant America Brochure

For the 1987 model year, pre-America combined sales totaled 203,252.  For 1988, it was 237,670, a 16.93% year-over-year increase.  It was a very short-term effort as production of the twins ceased at the Jefferson Avenue plant on December 9, 1988.  Oddly, this was to make way for the Omnirizon, which had been assembled at AMC’s old Kenosha plant after moving there from Belvidere.  While the Omnirizon moved from Belvidere to make way for the C-Body New Yorker and Dynasty, the Kenosha plant was ignominiously shut down.  Although Chrysler promised to keep the Omnirizon alive until the end of 1991 (they promised the same thing to Kenosha), production ceased on February 2, 1990, which is when the old Jefferson Avenue plant itself was closed.

The “America” designation was applied to the Shadow and Sundance for 1991, but that was just a stripper entry-level trim to replace the departed Omnirizon.  As far as I know, the America concept – a significant price cut (rather than just rebates or other incentives) backed by aggressive cost-cutting PLUS additional standard equipment PLUS discounted equipment packages, a catchy name, advertised heavily on a national basis rather than just regionally, and using a well-known, influential face (in this case Lee Iacocca’s) on the whole thing saying something like “This is how we beat the imports” – was never again applied to any model sold in the U.S. by any manufacturer.1989 Aries America 1

The question is why not?

First and foremost, many of these tactics began to be applied across the industry.  Over the next several years the Burger King method gave way to the option package concept when manufacturers saw how much they could increase the average transaction price.  For example, on the Omnirizon, power steering was only available in one of the discount packages, and more than 93 percent of 1987 America models came with power steering, so buyers needed to spend significantly more to get it than they spent for the stand-alone power steering option on the 1986 model (having had both an Omni and Horizon without power steering, I can tell you the car desperately needed it).  In addition, buyers could not get the stand-alone air conditioning or the cassette player unless they also ordered one of the discount packages.  It’s not hard to see why this has become common, and therefore why simplification would not work as well now as it did then.

As for getting part suppliers to cut their price, this was also the beginning of the era of guys like José Ignacio López de Arriortúa (Lopez Effect), Jacques Nasser (Jac the Knife), and Carlos Ghosn (Le Cost Cutter) who knew how to squeeze suppliers until their eyes popped.  Throughout the industry, this type of practice was applied to every car, leaving little room to extract any further concessions to try to effect a price cut.

Reliant America Options

Chrysler promising both Kenosha and Jefferson Avenue that they would be building the America cars for a certain period to extract a favorable contract – then reneging on that promise – would likely make any union suspicious of future promises of that nature.

Substantial price cuts by themselves do still happen, however, but these cuts tend to be the higher-priced trims and models.  Stellantis itself recently cut the price of the Durango R/T Plus from $54,990 to $47,490.  However, I believe that was due more to too-aggressive pricing – something Stellantis is egregiously guilty of – than from gaining any kind of efficiencies.

Besides to not having the ability to bring about something like the America program again, there are also the intangibles to consider.  While it was great that the Omnirizon held on to so many sales after the introduction of the Sundance/Shadow, how many higher-margin sales did Chrysler lose out on to people who bought the lower-margin car?  In addition, having such old models hanging around the showroom isn’t great for brand image.

Hoirzon America Interior scaled

Furthermore, the America program, while attracting new customers and keeping existing customers who were ready to trade in their old cars, also alienated many recent customers.  How would you have liked being that person who paid, say, $5,500 after rebates and a little negotiation for a base Horizon in early 1986 just before the America was introduced?  Not only did you miss out on all the additional standard features, but now your new Horizon was worth considerably less than it was just a few months before and you still had 43 payments to go.

Another aspect of the market that has changed which would discourage manufacturers from this type of program today is the increased popularity of leasing, and that where you typically see the most aggressive discounts.  The issue is that it’s strongly reliant on the mythical “residual value.”   In the example above, any leased 1986 Omnirizons – not that there were likely many leases on this type of model back then – would be worth significantly less than the contracted residual at the end of the lease, with Chrysler left holding the bag.  In addition, with so many off-lease one- to three-year-old late model vehicles on the market, many available as certified pre-owned with an extended warranty, how much of a market would there be for an obsolete new car at about the same price point?

There have been some aspects of the America program since then, such as keeping a current model in production with limited trims and options after the new model has been introduced at a higher price point, or restructuring the prices and options on a long-in-the-tooth model until the replacement arrives, but manufacturers had been doing that long before.  There have also been some novel pricing programs, like Ford’s “One Price” Escort 3- and 5-door hatchback in 1993 which added power steering, stereo, rear-window defroster, dual power mirrors and intermittent wipers for a non-negotiable $9,995 (a roughly $750 savings for those that don’t negotiate).

But there’s been nothing like the America program, which was a fascinating experiment in keeping an older model relevant, at least for the time.  Do you think there’s an opportunity for an America-type car today?  With car prices entering the stratosphere, there might be an argument for one.

 

Again, a big thank you to Aaron Severson and his extensive industry knowledge for his help with this post.

 

Related Reading:

Vintage Reviews: Car And Driver 1987 New Car Issues – Short Take Reviews For Domestics

COAL: 1989 Dodge Omni – My First (And Last) Brand-New Car

Curbside Classics: Plymouth Horizon And Dodge Omni – Detroit Finally Builds A Proper Small Car

CC Outtake: New Horizons

Curbside Classic: 1988 Plymouth Reliant America – Mom And Dad, Please Don’t

CC Capsule: 1989 Plymouth Reliant America 2-Door – Staring Down Extinction

COAL: 1988 Plymouth Reliant SE : Grandpa’s Legacy

COAL: 1988 Dodge Aries America: O K Car