Why Is My Jeep Wearing Those Tiny Tires In The Back? (Updated With The Answer)

IMG 2774

It looks ridiculous, but there’s actually a very good and logical reason I had some much smaller tires than the fronts mounted on the rear axle of my Jeep this morning. It’s up to you to guess what that reason is. If no one gets it, I’ll post the answer tomorrow morning.

Update: there were lots of good answers, several on the money and some close. Here’s my explanation at the bottom below:

IMG 2773

FWIW, these are a pair of cheap used 205-60R15 tires which are 24.7″ inches tall.  The front tires are 30″ tall. Does that help?

Answer: A number of you nailed it, starting with the first comment by Bobe. My CJ-5 came with 4.27 axles, a change (from 5.38s) Jeep made in about 1958 to accommodate the fact that more folks were driving their Jeeps on the highway. To compensate somewhat, they also made first and second gear on the three speed T90 transmission a bit lower, but it was a compromise, given the Hurricane F134’s 75 hp. And that was with the standard 600-16 tires, which are 28.3″ tall. So with the 30′ tires on my Jeep, it really felt geared too low. The gap between the gears was too large, it bogged when being upshifted, and third overdrive was utterly useless.

So I’ve been leaning towards putting in 5.38 axle gears. But it’s a big commitment as I’m not in a position to install the gears myself. And I’ve decided to also have Dana/Spicer Powr-Lok limited slip differentials installed at the same time. But how would it feel? Would I regret it?

On my pre-breakfast walk, I came up with the answer: put some smaller tires on the back that will essentially equal the final gearing of a 5.38 axle with a 30″ tire. That required a 24″ tire, so I went to my friendly nearby used tire store and had them install a pair of marginal 205-60R15s.

IMG 2768

And yesterday I finally got one of the three all-electronic distributors (OMID-AXA) actually working right, meaning with its mechanical advance functional. Due to very poor workmanship, the mechanical advance in the one that was in it and one of the two spares that came with it were locked in place. I compensated by cranking up the advance on the one that was in it, but when I mixed components (the one with working advance had a dead electronics module) I got one proper distributor and set the timing. It now advances to around 30 degrees at 2500 rpm; a bit higher than factory specs, but then those were set in the early ’50s when gas had 80 octanes, if that.

The combination of the smaller tires with the perkier engine was…surprising. It really steps out now, given its 75 hp. The shift into second actually gives a bit of a nudge instead of an anti-nudge. Second overdrive keeps the party going and third is now a great all-round gear from 30 or so up to 50. And now third overdrive is very usable; just right for the highway or tootling down a fairly straight country road. It was 27 degrees and I still have the top down, so I didn’t take it on the freeway, but I’m sure it will run readily at 60 or more if it’s fairly level.

Everything now happens quicker and brisker, which makes driving and shifting the two sticks more fun. A huge improvement. So yes, I will be having those 5.38 gears installed. And quite likely a set of Terra-Low gears in my transfer case to bring Low range from 2.46 to 3.15. I’m signed up for a big 4×4 Jamboree in Southern Utah in late January, so now I just need to get my installer to find the time. It’s way above my current pay grade.