Curbside Classic: Willys Jeep CJ-5 (1955-1963) – The Making Of An Icon

Which is more universally and instantly recognizable: A VW Beetle or a Jeep CJ? Hard to say; they’re both iconic. But unlike the Beetle, whose body shape (except for windows and a few other details) did not change from 1938 to 2003, the Jeep CJ did go through a number of distinct evolutions from its original military MB predecessor in 1941 to the end of the line in 1986. The CJ-5 was the most important and long-lived (1955-1983) of those evolutions, as it ushered in the rounded front body style that still informs the current JL Wrangler. As such, the CJ-5 might be better compared with the Porsche 911, in terms of a continuous evolution of their respective initial design elements.

The transition from the flat-fender MB and CJ-2/3 to the rounded CJ-5 was a bit convoluted, with some curious twists, bumps and turns, one of them called CJ-4. But then the Jeep was tailor made for that.

We’re not going to review the birth of the legendary WW2 MB Jeep here as we’ve already done that. Suffice it to say that it wasn’t exactly “styled” in the usual sense: form followed function here more than just about any other car.

Technically, there was a CJ-1 (“CJ” stands for Civilian Jeep), a slightly modified MB designed as an experimental prototype for civilian agricultural use and built in 1944, as that was considered the likely market for the Jeep after the war. But none still exist and there’s little documentation.

This ad from 1945 (before the war ended) clearly intimates what Willys-Overland saw as the greatest potential for the Jeep in the post war era, as an agricultural quasi-tractor. Of course it was also foreseen in other off-road roles, but recreational use was not on the list.

The next step in its evolution was the CJ2, also built in 1944-1945 and dubbed the “AgriJeep”, as it too was designed primarily for agricultural use. It was essentially an MB stripped of all military gear, with a lower (higher numerical) 5.38:1 axle gear ratio, a PTO, a drawbar and other items useful in its intended role, including tractor-tread tires. There were a number of minor body changes too. Some 40-45 were built, and a few have survived including this restored one (CJ2-09).

 

Here’s another ad from 1945, where a Jeep “invades” a Midwest farm and takes on multiple roles in the fields as well as on the road. Presumably this refers to the 40-50 “AgriJeeps” that were built and tested on farms.

In 1945 the definitive civilian Jeep, the CJ-2A, went into production. Although it was very heavily based on the MB, there were numerous differences, one key visual one being a change in the grille from 9 openings to 7, which has become a trademarked feature of all Jeeps since. The legendary 134 cubic inch “Go Devil” side valve four rated at 60 hp powered it as it had the MB.

In a nod to civilian use, the three-speed Borg-Warner T-90 transmission had a column shifter. Only a singe driver’s seat was standard. 214,760 Jeep CJ-2As were built from 1945 to 1949.

The CJ-3A took over from the CJ-2A in 1949. The most obvious difference is in the one-piece windshield and its construction. There were other small differences such as a modified rear wheel well to allow the driver’s seat to be moved back a bit. But largely it was still very much like the MB Jeep, at least in its basic shape and proportions, but it would be the last of that family.

The 2WD Dispatcher DJ-3A continued to be built until 1964 based on the CJ3A body, including in this Surrey version.

 

Although Willys Chief Engineer Barney Roos had done a remarkable job improving Willys’ ancient flathead four, boosting its power substantially to 60 hp for the MB Jeep, it was deemed a bit lacking in the larger and heavier post-war Willys Station Wagon and truck. So Roos went at it again, giving the “Go Devil” a new F-head cylinder head as well as a new name: Hurricane.  The change to overhead intake valves allowed both valves to be larger, thus improving the breathing of the little long-stroke four. Power increased from 60 to 75 hp, and torque was up from 105 to 114 lb.ft.

The first big change in the CJ’s looks came in 1953 when its flat hood was raised quite considerably in the CJ-3B to make room for the taller Hurricane engine. Somewhat curiously, the CJ-3B was built alongside the CJ-5 all the way to 1964, and military versions for exports were built until 1968.

The tall-hood CJ-3B was the basis for the license built Mahindra and Mitsubishi Jeep, which was built with its distinctive front end all the way through 1998. This is a 1990’s Mitsubishi Jeep turbo-diesel that was imported to the US by an acquaintance in Port Orford, here next to my friend Allen’s CJ3A.

Common knowledge says the CJ-5 then appeared in 1955, two years after the boxy CJ-3B and featuring the more modern and distinctive rounded hood and fenders. But in a curious twist to the CJ story, the rounded taller hood to clear the Hurricane engine was already seen back in 1951, on the one and only stillborn CJ-4M (above).

There’s also photos of it in military garb, dubbed M-38E1. I’m not sure if there was more than one prototype or if it was de-militarized, but in any case, the CJ-4M was a half step towards the definitive CJ-5, having a similar rounded front end to clear the taller engine and and the front end and fenders were full width, not needing to flare out to meet the body tub as in the earlier CJ’s. But the rest of the body tub from about midway from the side openings was essentially unchanged

One (or the only) CJ-4 has survived, having been sold to Willys suspension engineer Miguel Ordorica. He talked the company into selling  him a civilian model in 1955 for a mere $300, taking his unique Jeep to his property in Toledo, Ohio, he used it for hauling logs, ploughing snow, and generally making itself useful. It last surfaced with a new owner in 1997.

It seems rather odd that Willys would create this new rounded front in 1951 for the CJ-4 to clear the taller engine, yet then in 1953 it came out with the rather retrograde CJ-3B. The CJ-3B was kept in production alongside the CJ-5, priced in 1955 a bit lower at $1411 compared to $1475. The CJ-3B eas also licen

There’s a fairly good explanation. In 1953, the same year the CJ-3B arrived the military got the new M38-A1 with quite a few significant changes, including a one inch longer wheelbase (now 81″) , a heavier frame, longer rear leaf springs and a longer body at the rear to accommodate those longer springs as well as to increase rear cargo and/or seating room. The body tub was now also full width at the area under the cowl.

And of course the front end and the rest of the body now had the definitive styling and features that would be seen in the civilian CJ-5. But that would have to wait two more years. Why? Supposedly the military had first dibs on the improved Jeep, and this was during the Korean conflict. Willys still depended heavily on military contracts, and it’s probably fairly safe to assume that much or a significant portion of the M38-A1’s development and tooling costs were rolled into their military contract.

In 1955 the “All New Streamlined” Willys CJ-5 arrived. It was a bit bigger, mostly in some 5″ of extra length at the rear. And the full-width body created a bit more room for the front passengers and their feet.

This makes driving the CJ-5 a bit easier to drive when wearing big boots or such; the CJ2-3 is really quite tight in that regard. And there was even a glove box now. But mechanically there was no real difference between the CJ-3B and the CJ-5; all the usual classic early Jeep CJ components: the tough Hurricane four, a B/W T-90 three-speed transmission, a Dana 18 two-speed transfer case, Dana 25 or 27 front axles, a Dana 44 rear axle and 6.00 x 16 tires.

This immaculately restored CJ-5 was sitting right in front of us, at the local Friendly Food Court. It must have pulled in to park while we were ordering, so I missed the driver and didn’t have the chance to ask him what year it is.

Given that it’s still got the Willys (pronounced Willis) markings, it’s a 1964 or earlier. Starting in 1965, Jeeps were officially now from Kaiser-Jeep and labeled as such.

Standard 15″ wheels and tires replaced these 16 inchers in mid-1963, so that narrows it down just a wee bit more, although the 16″ wheels were optional through 1971. These are ND (military style) tires, which were also standard through 1963 (based on ad pictures), so that’s not going to help us narrow down the model year for this Jeep. There were apparently very few changes during these Willys years (1955-1963).

So unless the owner sees this post on the web and chimes in, the exact year of this CJ-5 will have to remain a mystery.

The front seat is the optional 2/3 – 1/3 spilt bench. Given the narrowness of the CJ and the three levers protruding from the floor, it’s a bit hard to imagine anyone riding in that middle position. But things were different back then, and folks were generally narrower. Still…

The rear seat is a good place to get some wind in one’s hair.

I haven’t encountered a restored early CJ-5 before, so it was fun having this one drop in for dinner entertainment.

I’d happily drive off in this Jeep. And I’m even good with the Hurricane four; it’s quite adequate for the back roads and off-road driving I’m likely to subject it to.

It reminds me of the red four-cylinder TJ Wrangler we rented in Silverton, CO some years back. It was a chilly mid-October morning as we headed off on the Colorado Alpine Loop, but as the sun hit we stopped and put the top down. Here we are crossing Engineer Pass (el. 12,800′). The 2.5 four in the TJ was perfectly adequate for the job.

Time to say goodbye to the face that’s become iconic.

 

Related CC reading:

Curbside Classic: 1945 Willys Jeep MB – The Icon Of Freedom  by P.N.

Curbside Classic: 1947 Willys-Overland CJ-2A by M. Butts

Curbside Classic: 1948 Willys Jeep CJ2A – In The Beginning by J.P. Cavanaugh

Curbside Classic: Kaiser Jeep CJ-5 – Transcendent Independent by R. Kim

The History of The Curious F-Head Engine  by P.N.