1957 Oldsmobile Starfire 98 Convertible: A Jade Mist Charmer Shows Us That There’s Life Left In The 1950s Car Market

Driver front 3q picture of green 1957 Oldsmobile Starfire 98 Convertible

It’s a fact of life that each generation celebrates the goods that they remember from their youth, so it’s melancholy but not unexpected that collector cars from the 1930s to the 1950s have begun their inevitable decline in popularity. But don’t throw dirt on the grave just yet, because nice versions of flashy examples of 1950s cars are still bringing in some impressive bids at the auction sites; for example, this 1957 Oldsmobile Starfire 88 Convertible was bid up to $70,000-plus on Hemmings Auctions, but it didn’t meet reserve. It’s a one-time AACA award winner located at West Coast Classics in Torrance, California, and it’s now listed with a price tag of $89,250.

Driver profile of green 1957 Oldsmobile Starfire 98

It’s unsurprising that if any 1950s car were to maintain its value, it would be a fancy convertible, especially one in an alluring color combination such as Jade Mist Iridescent and Alcan White. And while some 1957 Oldsmobiles began to show signs that Harley Earl missed the mark a bit, hardly anyone could look at this long, low Starfire 98 and think it’s an unattractive car. By the way, the name itself, Starfire 98, was given to all models in the 98 line for 1957.

J-2 Introduction Brochure/Over-Drive Magazine
J-2 Introduction Brochure/Over-Drive Magazine

Another reason for this 98’s staying power is its engine, a 300-horsepower 371 with the newly optional “J-2” package, which was a deal at just $83. For comparison, the Jetaway Hydra-Matic, which most Oldsmobiles were ordered with, was a $215 option on lower-line models (but was standard on the 98).

The J-2 (and all Starfire 98s) had dual exhausts, which increased the engine’s power to the rear wheels. The extra gross horsepower came from a fairly straightforward three-two-barrel carburetor setup that increased the 371’s rating by 23 over the standard four-barrel engine while operating on the center two-barrel in most driving situations.

1957 Oldsmobile Starfire 98 Engine Compartment with 371-cubic-inch J-2 engine option

This J-2 was also ordered with the $430 air conditioning system, but most luxury equipment was standard on the Starfire 98, including power steering and power brakes. Aside from the stickers on the air cleaner and three wing nuts holding it on, you’d be hard pressed to tell that this is a J-2 car. For a big 1950s Oldsmobile, maintenance room looks tight under the hood, which is an indictment of the car’s power options rather than its packaging.

1957 Oldsmobile Starfire 98 interior with green and white upholstery

If anything looks aged on the Oldsmobile, it’s the upholstery, which is showing signs of wear, but aside from that, the interior is standard 1957 Oldsmobile, which is not standard at all. There’s enough bright trim to cause problems on sunny days, and this one has a power seat, power windows (which were standard), and a power top. For those who are searching for the power window switches, they are located at the corners of the dashboard near the doglegs.

1957 Oldsmobile Starfire 98 Convertible luggage compartment

The trunk is trimmed like most luxury GM products of the time period, with a shaped board liner covering the inner quarter panels and hinges.

1957 Oldsmobile Starfire 98 Convertible undercarriage showing dual exhaust system

The undercarriage pictures show the beefy X-braced frame, dual exhausts, and Jetaway Hydra-Matic. The undercarriage is certainly no longer show detailed (if it ever was), but it looks clean and solid.

Passenger rear 3q picture of green 1957 Oldsmobile Starfire 98 Convertible with white top

Historically, the Chevrolet has been the 1957 GM car to grab the attention of the public at large, but one look at this Starfire 98 makes one wonder if the public at large missed the mark. The Starfire 98 Convertible was not inexpensive, but it was fairly popular, selling 8,278 units, which made it the most popular convertible in the lineup. Given that the 98 Convertible was over $700 more dear than a comparable Super 88 to start, that may sound surprising, but remember that the 98 came with a nice list of standard features that were optional on other lines. And with an extra four inches of wheelbase and eight inches of length, it just looks right, which has helped to keep the Starfire 98 popular even when some other 1950s cars are cooling off.

Related Reading

Car Show Classic: 1957 Oldsmobile Super 88 – Pressed In A Book (by me)

Auction Capsule: 1957 Oldsmobile Ninety-Eight Convertible – For 57 Years, A Fair-Weather Ride (by Jim Grey)

1957–1958 Oldsmobile J-2 Engine: Similar To Pontiac Tri-Power, It Was Developed First (by Aaron Severson)